1230 S Oakland Avenue, Pasadena, California 91106, Pasadena, 91106 - 7 bed, 8 bath

1230 S Oakland Avenue, Pasadena, California 91106 home-pic-0
ACTIVE$12,000,000$8,713/sqft
Est. Value: $12,788,791
6%
BelowEstimate
1230 S Oakland Avenue, Pasadena, California 91106
7Beds
8Baths
8,713Sqft
107,624Lot

Price Vs. Estimate

The estimated value ($12,788,791.16) is $788,791.16 (6%) higher than the list price ($12,000,000). This property may be underpriced.

Key pros and cons

Top Pros:
High Available Lot Utilization: The property has a large lot size, which is more than 4 times of its living area. lot size in square feet = 107624, living area = 8713.
Top Cons:
MLS Listing Discrepancy: Living area discrepancy between mls listing and other public or private record. mls listing living area = 8713, other record living area = 7148.

Compared to the nearby listings

Price:$12.00M vs avg $1.91M (+$10,092,500)97%
Size:8,713 sqft vs avg 2,055 sqft97%
Price/sqft:$1.4K vs avg $98697%

More Insights

Built in 1913 (113 years old).
Condition: This historic 1913 estate, while old, has been meticulously maintained and significantly updated in key areas. The main kitchen features high-end, modern appliances (Wolf range, Sub-Zero style refrigerator) and updated cabinetry/finishes, while the main bathroom boasts modern fixtures, white marble, and a glass-enclosed shower. The guest house is also noted as 'recently updated with full kitchen and BA.' Original architectural elements like mahogany paneling, marble flooring, and restored hardwood are described as being in 'exceptional condition.' The property is move-in ready with no immediate renovation required. Although the listing notes potential age-related system updates (electrical, plumbing, HVAC) as a weakness, the visible areas and overall description indicate a property that has undergone extensive, high-quality renovations within the last 5-15 years, aligning with the 'Good' criteria.
Year Built
1913
Close
-
List price
$12M
Original List price
$12M
Price/Sqft
$1,377
HOA
-
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
P1-25264
Home ConditionGood
Features
Good View: City Lights, Neighborhood, Trees/Woods
Pool
Patio
ViewCity Lights,Neighborhood,Trees/Woods

About this home

//Charles A Goodyear House, 'Knollcrest' by G. Lawrence Stimson, 1913// Built in 1913 for lumber baron Charles Goodyear and his wife, Henrietta, Knollcrest occupies 2.5 acres (Lots 18 and 19) within the original Oak Knoll subdivision. Widely regarded as one of the finest homesites in the development, its commanding position atop a gentle knoll--overlooking a sweeping front lawn--earned the estate its enduring name. //The residence was designed by prominent architect G. Lawrence Stimson, best known for the Wrigley Mansion. It is said that Goodyear commissioned the home, in part, to incorporate his extensive collection of custom-made furnishings and artifacts, resulting in a structure conceived to be entirely fireproof. Original wrought-iron gates frame the estate's 330' frontage along Oakland Ave, connected by a circular drive culminating in a porte-cochere. A rare secondary driveway, running N/S with automatic gate, is accessed via Allendale Rd. //True to Stimson's architectural language, the main residence features stately mahogany-paneled public rooms w/10' ceilings, upper-level bedrooms w/9' ceilings, hand-carved moldings, marble flooring and staircase, and living room w/restored Caucasian walnut floors accented by ebony inlay. Remarkably, much of the original woodwork and artisan-crafted built-ins remain intact and in exceptional condition. Living space spans three levels, with additional attic area above. //A secondary structure--recently updated w/full kitchen and BA--serves as a guest house, adjacent to garage w/BA, and pool. In total, Knollcrest comprises 8,713 sf of living space across all structures, complemented by an additional 5,206 sf of garage/storage space. //Following the Goodyears, the estate was stewarded by a succession of prominent families, including U.S. Steel president Thomas Cole and department store scion and philanthropist Samuel Robinson, before being acquired by the current owner in 1966. In 1968, Knollcrest was selected as the 4th Pasadena Showcase House and has since served as the backdrop for numerous motion pictures. //Defined by its rich history, architectural pedigree, prominent setting, and intact original acreage, Knollcrest stands among Pasadena's landmark estates. Offered for the first time in six decades, it represents a rare opportunity to steward a significant Los Angeles family estate for generations to come.

B
Brent Chang
Listing Agent

Price History

Date
Event
Price
08/21/25
Sold
$10,500,000
Condition Rating
Good

This historic 1913 estate, while old, has been meticulously maintained and significantly updated in key areas. The main kitchen features high-end, modern appliances (Wolf range, Sub-Zero style refrigerator) and updated cabinetry/finishes, while the main bathroom boasts modern fixtures, white marble, and a glass-enclosed shower. The guest house is also noted as 'recently updated with full kitchen and BA.' Original architectural elements like mahogany paneling, marble flooring, and restored hardwood are described as being in 'exceptional condition.' The property is move-in ready with no immediate renovation required. Although the listing notes potential age-related system updates (electrical, plumbing, HVAC) as a weakness, the visible areas and overall description indicate a property that has undergone extensive, high-quality renovations within the last 5-15 years, aligning with the 'Good' criteria.
Pros & Cons

Pros

High Available Lot Utilization: The property has a large lot size, which is more than 4 times of its living area. lot size in square feet = 107624, living area = 8713.
Historical Significance & Architectural Pedigree: Designed by renowned architect G. Lawrence Stimson (known for the Wrigley Mansion) and built in 1913, 'Knollcrest' is a landmark estate with a rich history, having been stewarded by prominent families and selected as a Pasadena Showcase House.
Expansive Estate & Prominent Setting: Occupying 2.5 acres atop a gentle knoll, the property offers a commanding position with a sweeping front lawn, ensuring privacy and prestige within the original Oak Knoll subdivision.
Exceptional Original Craftsmanship & Preservation: The residence boasts remarkably intact original features, including stately mahogany-paneled public rooms, hand-carved moldings, marble flooring, and artisan-crafted built-ins, all in exceptional condition.
Extensive Living & Auxiliary Spaces: With 8,713 sqft of living space across all structures, including a recently updated guest house with a full kitchen and bath, plus an additional 5,206 sqft of garage/storage, the estate offers ample room for living and amenities.
Unique Fireproof Construction: The home was originally conceived to be entirely fireproof, a rare and significant feature for a property of its age, adding to its structural integrity and historical value.

Cons

MLS Listing Discrepancy: Living area discrepancy between mls listing and other public or private record. mls listing living area = 8713, other record living area = 7148.
Recently Sold Property: The property was recently sold within the past year on 2025-08-21. The sold price is $10,500,000.00.
Age-Related System Updates: Built in 1913, the property may require significant investment in updating major systems such as electrical, plumbing, and HVAC, which are not explicitly detailed as modernized in the description.
High Maintenance & Operating Costs: A 2.5-acre estate with over 8,700 sqft of living space and extensive original features will demand substantial ongoing maintenance, landscaping, utility, and property tax expenses.
Limited Buyer Pool: The property's significant historical value, grand scale, and high list price of $12,000,000 target a very niche market of affluent buyers seeking a landmark estate, potentially leading to a longer market time.
Browse Properties by State Browse housing market trends by state