RealKey
‪(213) 433-7766‬

129 Sunnyside Avenue, Santa Cruz, California 95062, Santa Cruz, 95062 - bed, bath

129 Sunnyside Avenue, Santa Cruz, California 95062 home-pic-0
ACTIVE UNDER CONTRACT$1,795,000
129 Sunnyside Avenue, Santa Cruz, California 95062
0Bed
0Bath
2,144Sqft
5,750Lot

Price Vs. Estimate

Estimation data not available

Key pros and cons

Top Pros:
Exceptional Income Potential & Flexibility: This legal duplex, currently tenant-occupied with all rooms filled, offers immediate income. Its R1 zoning and existing bonus studio provide significant potential for converting the studio to an ADU and adding further units, maximizing rental revenue.
Top Cons:
High Price Point: The list price of $1,795,000 represents a significant investment, which may limit the pool of potential buyers.

Compared to the nearby listings

Price:$1.79M vs avg $1.90M ($-102,500)50%
Size:2,144 sqft vs avg 2,451.5 sqft50%
Price/sqft:$837 vs avg $75550%

More Insights

This property has been on the market for 99 days.
Built in 1903 (122 years old).
Condition: Despite its 1903 build year, the property has undergone a 'complete system overhaul including electrical, plumbing, roof, and even a rebuilt foundation,' indicating significant recent investment in its core integrity. The description also states 'updated kitchens, baths, and flooring.' While some interior images show worn carpet and basic light fixtures, suggesting the cosmetic updates may not be high-end or very recent, the fundamental systems are described as modern and sound. This makes the property move-in ready with major components functional and within expected lifespan, aligning with a 'Good' condition score.
Year Built
1903
Close
-
List price
$1.79M
Original List price
$1.79M
Price/Sqft
$837
HOA
-
Days on market
99 Days
Sold On
2025-09-17
MLS number
ML82010413
Home ConditionGood
Features
Good View:
Deck
Patio
View-

About this home

Craftsman Garden Duplex with Detached Shop/Garage plus Bonus Studio. Tenant Occupied with all rooms filled. Tucked into a quiet cul-de-sac on the Eastside, just blocks from local favorite markets, shops and restaurants. This nearly fully renovated income property offers exceptional flexibility and charm. The main duplex features two spacious units with updated kitchens, baths, and flooring, while a separate detached unit permitted as an art studio adds additional living or rental potential. Behind the vintage 1903 facade lies a complete system overhaul including electrical, plumbing, roof, and even a rebuilt foundation. A detached garage and carport provide ample storage or utility space, and the mature yard invites outdoor enjoyment. The R1 zoning and legal duplex status affords additional capacity for converting the existing art studio to an ADU, with room to add more units and/or ADU's. The property blends historic character with modern performance, all within easy reach of beaches, UCSC, and shopping.

Condition Rating
Good
Despite its 1903 build year, the property has undergone a 'complete system overhaul including electrical, plumbing, roof, and even a rebuilt foundation,' indicating significant recent investment in its core integrity. The description also states 'updated kitchens, baths, and flooring.' While some interior images show worn carpet and basic light fixtures, suggesting the cosmetic updates may not be high-end or very recent, the fundamental systems are described as modern and sound. This makes the property move-in ready with major components functional and within expected lifespan, aligning with a 'Good' condition score.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Exceptional Income Potential & Flexibility: This legal duplex, currently tenant-occupied with all rooms filled, offers immediate income. Its R1 zoning and existing bonus studio provide significant potential for converting the studio to an ADU and adding further units, maximizing rental revenue.
Extensive Modern Renovations: Despite its 1903 build, the property has undergone a complete system overhaul, including electrical, plumbing, roof, and a rebuilt foundation. The main units feature updated kitchens, baths, and flooring, blending historic charm with modern performance.
Prime Eastside Santa Cruz Location: Situated in a quiet cul-de-sac on the desirable Eastside, the property is just blocks from local markets, shops, and restaurants, and offers easy access to beaches, UCSC, and other amenities.
Versatile Additional Structures: The property includes a detached shop/garage, a carport, and a bonus studio, providing ample storage, utility space, and additional living or rental potential beyond the main duplex.
Historic Charm Preserved: The vintage 1903 Craftsman facade maintains its historic character, offering aesthetic appeal while being backed by thoroughly updated and modern internal systems.

Cons

High Price Point: The list price of $1,795,000 represents a significant investment, which may limit the pool of potential buyers.
Tenant Occupied Status: While beneficial for immediate income, the property being fully tenant-occupied could complicate showings, inspections, or a new owner's plans for immediate occupancy or specific renovations.
Extended Days on Market: With 99 days on the market, despite being 'Active Under Contract,' it suggests the property may have faced initial market resistance or pricing challenges.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse housing market trends by state