139 Avenida Sierra, San Clemente, California 92672, San Clemente, 92672 - bed, bath

139 Avenida Sierra, San Clemente, California 92672 home-pic-0
ACTIVE$5,250,000
139 Avenida Sierra, San Clemente, California 92672
0Bed
0Bath
3,678Sqft
18,124Lot

Price Vs. Estimate

Estimation data not available

Key pros and cons

Top Pros:
Exceptional Development & Subdivision Potential: The property spans three separate parcels with an expansive 18,124 sqft lot, offering significant potential to subdivide and build multiple single-family homes or a new structure to maximize panoramic ocean views.
Top Cons:
High Barrier to Entry (Price Point): The substantial list price of $5.25 million represents a significant capital outlay, potentially narrowing the pool of prospective buyers.

Compared to the nearby listings

Price:$5.25M vs avg $1.69M (+$3,565,000)90%
Size:3,678 sqft vs avg 2,249 sqft79%
Price/sqft:$1.4K vs avg $72893%

More Insights

Built in 1948 (77 years old).
Condition: The property was built in 1948, making the existing structures 76 years old. The MLS description explicitly lists 'Age of Existing Structures & Renovation Needs' as a weakness, stating that the buildings are 'older, suggesting potential for deferred maintenance, necessary renovations, or significant upgrades to modernize units or meet current standards.' While the property is currently income-generating with rented units, the emphasis on its development potential (subdivision, building new structures) and the lack of any interior photos (especially of kitchens and bathrooms) strongly indicate that the existing structures require substantial repairs and rehabilitation. Without evidence of recent major renovations, a property of this age is likely to have outdated systems and components that are past their expected lifespan, aligning with a 'poor' condition rating rather than merely 'fair' which implies minor updates.
Year Built
1948
Close
-
List price
$5.25M
Original List price
$5.5M
Price/Sqft
$1,427
HOA
-
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
LG25009353
Home ConditionPoor
Features
Good View: Hills, Neighborhood, Peek-A-Boo
Deck
Patio
ViewHills, Neighborhood, Peek-A-Boo

About this home

135/137/139 Avenida Sierra | Located on the ocean side of the 5 freeway in an established San Clemente neighborhood, this multi-unit income property could be the opportunity of a lifetime. Set on three separate parcels in close proximity to local beaches, parks, the Metrolink and many shopping/dining options, the property includes approximately 18,000 square feet and five units. An ocean view is available from the upper unit and the potential exists to build a new structure up from the spacious parking lot to capitalize on panoramic views of the ocean, city lights and hillsides. Currently, the property grosses over $10,200/month; 4 of the units are rented and records are available from the owner. An additional ADU could be upfitted to receive a permit and potentially bring another income stream totaling around $1,500/month. A 3-car garage and shared laundry add to the current investment value and versatility. With the potential to subdivide and build three single family homes, the property could deliver a substantial return on investment. The options are endless: live in the upper unit and enjoy the ocean breeze while renting the others, create a family compound, realize a 1031 Exchange to avoid capital gains or purchase solely as an investment and avoid the stress/fluctuations of the financial markets. Considering the premium location and the idea that the demand for Southern California real estate is unlikely to abate, the time to act is now. With the potential for appreciation and a current income stream, this versatile property could be a chance to build a legacy spanning multiple generations. Buyer and buyer's agent are responsible for verifying all information for ultimate use.

Condition Rating
Poor

The property was built in 1948, making the existing structures 76 years old. The MLS description explicitly lists 'Age of Existing Structures & Renovation Needs' as a weakness, stating that the buildings are 'older, suggesting potential for deferred maintenance, necessary renovations, or significant upgrades to modernize units or meet current standards.' While the property is currently income-generating with rented units, the emphasis on its development potential (subdivision, building new structures) and the lack of any interior photos (especially of kitchens and bathrooms) strongly indicate that the existing structures require substantial repairs and rehabilitation. Without evidence of recent major renovations, a property of this age is likely to have outdated systems and components that are past their expected lifespan, aligning with a 'poor' condition rating rather than merely 'fair' which implies minor updates.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Exceptional Development & Subdivision Potential: The property spans three separate parcels with an expansive 18,124 sqft lot, offering significant potential to subdivide and build multiple single-family homes or a new structure to maximize panoramic ocean views.
Robust Income-Generating Asset: Currently a multi-unit property with five units (four rented), generating over $10,200/month, with additional income potential from an ADU, providing immediate cash flow.
Prime Coastal San Clemente Location: Situated on the ocean side of the 5 freeway, offering easy access to local beaches, parks, Metrolink, and a vibrant array of shopping and dining options in a highly desirable Southern California market.
Versatile Investment Opportunities: Offers diverse options for investors, including a 1031 exchange, creating a family compound, living in one unit while renting others, or a pure investment play with long-term appreciation potential.
Existing Ocean Views & Enhancement Potential: The upper unit currently enjoys an ocean view, with significant potential to enhance and capture panoramic ocean, city lights, and hillside views through new construction.

Cons

High Barrier to Entry (Price Point): The substantial list price of $5.25 million represents a significant capital outlay, potentially narrowing the pool of prospective buyers.
Age of Existing Structures & Renovation Needs: Built in 1948, the current structures are older, suggesting potential for deferred maintenance, necessary renovations, or significant upgrades to modernize units or meet current standards, especially if development plans are not immediately pursued.
Due Diligence Required on Unit Status/Permitting: While described as a 5-unit property, the sub-type is 'Quadruplex,' and only 4 units are currently rented. This implies a need for thorough buyer due diligence regarding permitting, current condition, and rental agreements for all units, including the potential ADU.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse housing market trends by state