RealKey
‪(213) 433-7766‬

1789 Nantucket Place, Costa Mesa, California 92627, Costa Mesa, 92627 - 3 bed, 3 bath

1789 Nantucket Place, Costa Mesa, California 92627 home-pic-0
ACTIVE$3,995,000
1789 Nantucket Place, Costa Mesa, California 92627
3Beds
3Baths
2,376Sqft
4,760Lot

Price Vs. Estimate

The estimated value ($2,894,330.06) is $1,100,669.94 (27%) lower than the list price ($3,995,000). This property may be overpriced.

Key pros and cons

Top Pros:
Great Schools: Elementary School: Hyer Elementary School (10/10). High School: Highland Park High School (9/10).
Top Cons:
Significant Price Discrepancy: The list price of $3.995M is substantially higher than the estimated property value of approximately $2.89M, suggesting a potential overpricing or a challenge in justifying the premium to some buyers.

Compared to the nearby listings

Price:$4.00M vs avg $1.75M (+$2,245,000)96%
Size:2,376 sqft vs avg 1,762 sqft78%
Price/sqft:$1.7K vs avg $1.0K95%

More Insights

Built in 1991 (34 years old).
Condition: This property has been fully rebuilt, expanded, and upgraded from the ground up by the owner, featuring high-end finishes and all new systems (electrical, plumbing, HVAC). The kitchen boasts modern flat-panel cabinetry, integrated high-end appliances, unique stone countertops, and sleek fixtures. Bathrooms are equally luxurious with floating vanities, large format tiling, glass-enclosed showers, and premium Dornbracht and Vola fixtures. The entire home showcases a consistent coastal modern aesthetic with light wood flooring, recessed lighting, Monumental-brand sliders, a Lutron smart lighting system, dual-zone HVAC, and tankless water heaters, indicating a virtually new condition with no deferred maintenance.
Year Built
1991
Close
-
List price
$4M
Original List price
$4M
Price/Sqft
$1,681
HOA
$300
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
PW25127054
Home ConditionExcellent
Features
Excellent View: Catalina, Coastline
Patio
ViewCatalina, Coastline

About this home

Rebuilt Luxury with Catalina Views | Gated Community | With ADU - Unobstructed Catalina Island views. Gated community. Fully rebuilt, expanded, and upgraded coastal modern home with high-end finishes and total privacy. Offered for the first time in nearly 20 years, this 3,250 sq. ft. home was rebuilt from the ground up by the owner—not a flip—and is located on a premium private lot with no visible neighbors. Enjoy forever Catalina views from nearly every inch of the property. The home includes an attached, fully integrated ADU (Accessory Dwelling Unit) and sits in a quiet, wildlife-rich location with daily views of owls, hawks, and falcons in flight. Features: Gated community with low HOA dues ($300/month), Panoramic, Unobstructed Catalina views, 400-amp electrical panel (future-ready for spa, EVs, etc.), 12-ft Hestan outdoor kitchen with 42” BBQ, kegerator, refrigeration, Space for spa, outdoor heaters, and more, Monumental-brand sliders, bi-fold doors, and windows, Lutron smart lighting system throughout, Dual-zone HVAC (3-ton & 5-ton units), Two tankless water heaters, Dornbracht and Vola fixtures. All new systems—electrical, plumbing, HVAC—ensure turn-key, high-performance living. This is a rare offering combining luxury, seclusion, and long-term value.

Nearby schools

4/10
Whittier Elementary School
Public,•PK-6•0.2mi
6/10
Victoria Elementary School
Public,•PK-6•0.9mi
4/10
Pomona Elementary School
Public,•PK-6•1.2mi
4/10
Everett A. Rea Elementary School
Public,•PK-6•1.3mi
3/10
Wilson Elementary School
Public,•PK-6•1.3mi
/10
Woodland Elementary School
Public,•PK-2•2.3mi
4/10
College Park Elementary School
Public,•PK-6•2.4mi
8/10
Heinz Kaiser Elementary School
Public,•3-6•2.4mi
7/10
Adams Elementary School
Public,•PK-6•2.5mi
8/10
Newport Heights Elementary School
Public,•K-6•2.6mi
9/10
Newport Elementary School
Public,•PK-6•2.7mi
7/10
John J Pershing Elementary School
Public,•PK-5•1219.9mi
10/10
Hyer Elementary School
Public,•PK-4•1220.7mi
6/10
Preston Hollow Elementary School
Public,•PK-5•1220.8mi
7/10
Horace Ensign Intermediate School
Public,•7-8•2.2mi
4/10
Charles W. Tewinkle Middle School
Public,•7-8•3.5mi
5/10
Benjamin Franklin Middle School
Public,•6-8•1221.3mi
8/10
Highland Park Middle School
Public,•7-8•1221.5mi
8/10
Mcculloch Intermediate School
Public,•5-6•1221.5mi
5/10
Estancia High School
Public,•9-12•1.5mi
7/10
Newport Harbor High School
Public,•9-12•2.1mi
6/10
Costa Mesa High School
Public,•7-12•3.0mi
9/10
Highland Park High School
Public,•9-12•1220.5mi
4/10
Hillcrest High School
Public,•9-12•1221.4mi
Condition Rating
Excellent
This property has been fully rebuilt, expanded, and upgraded from the ground up by the owner, featuring high-end finishes and all new systems (electrical, plumbing, HVAC). The kitchen boasts modern flat-panel cabinetry, integrated high-end appliances, unique stone countertops, and sleek fixtures. Bathrooms are equally luxurious with floating vanities, large format tiling, glass-enclosed showers, and premium Dornbracht and Vola fixtures. The entire home showcases a consistent coastal modern aesthetic with light wood flooring, recessed lighting, Monumental-brand sliders, a Lutron smart lighting system, dual-zone HVAC, and tankless water heaters, indicating a virtually new condition with no deferred maintenance.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Great Schools: Elementary School: Hyer Elementary School (10/10). High School: Highland Park High School (9/10).
Unobstructed Panoramic Views: The property boasts rare, unobstructed panoramic views of Catalina Island and the coastline from nearly every inch, a highly desirable and value-driving feature.
Extensive Luxury Rebuild: The home has been fully rebuilt, expanded, and upgraded from the ground up by the owner, featuring high-end finishes and all new systems (electrical, plumbing, HVAC) ensuring turn-key, high-performance living.
Attached Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU): Includes an attached, fully integrated ADU, offering versatile options for rental income, multi-generational living, or a dedicated guest/office space.
Gated Community & Privacy: Located within a gated community on a premium private lot with no visible neighbors, providing enhanced security, exclusivity, and a tranquil, wildlife-rich environment.
Premium Modern Features: Equipped with state-of-the-art amenities including a 400-amp electrical panel (EV/spa ready), 12-ft Hestan outdoor kitchen, Monumental-brand sliders, Lutron smart lighting, dual-zone HVAC, and high-end Dornbracht/Vola fixtures.

Cons

Significant Price Discrepancy: The list price of $3.995M is substantially higher than the estimated property value of approximately $2.89M, suggesting a potential overpricing or a challenge in justifying the premium to some buyers.
High Price Point: The nearly $4 million asking price, even for a luxury property, targets a very specific and limited buyer demographic, which could potentially extend the time on market.
Ongoing HOA Dues: Despite being described as 'low' for a gated community, the $300/month HOA fee represents an additional recurring cost that some single-family home buyers might prefer to avoid.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse housing market trends by state