236 S Shaffer Street, Orange, California 92866, Orange, 92866 - bed, bath

236 S Shaffer Street, Orange, California 92866 home-pic-0
ACTIVE$1,998,000
236 S Shaffer Street, Orange, California 92866
0Bed
0Bath
4,000Sqft
6,464Lot
Year Built
1928
Close
-
List price
$2M
Original List price
$2M
Price/Sqft
$500
HOA
-
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
PW25252361
Home ConditionFair
Features
Deck
Patio
View-

About this home

We found 3 Cons,5 Pros. Rank: price - $2.00M(92th), sqft - 4000(92th), beds - undefined(50th), baths - undefined(50th).

Welcome home to 236 S. Shaffer, one of the largest 2 on a lot homes in Old Towne Orange, just a few blocks from the plaza! The front house features a 2-story 4-bedroom plus office/den or 5th bedroom, 2.5 bath, with a main floor bedroom and bath. Large living room that has an entertainment area with a wrap-around bar, a fireplace that opens to the formal dining room and kitchen. The kitchen features a breakfast bar, center island, and walk-in pantry. A convenient "mud room” that has a guest powder room and laundry room. upstairs, 3 bedrooms including a 480 sqft primary bedroom, a walk-in closet, and a 250 sqft enclosed sun room. Lots of possibilities. The guest house, 431 E. Washington, features 2 primary suites, each has their own bathroom, a large living room, and dining area that is open to the kitchen with a breakfast bar. The larger primary has lots of closet space and sliding glass doors to a large private sun balcony. Over 4000 sq. ft. of living area combined, this is a one-of-a-kind, rare find in Old Towne. 4 over-sized single car garages, central heating and air in both units, whole house fan in main house, new blinds and carpet, and golden teak hand scraped wood floors in the main house. Beautifully landscaped grounds, front yard blooming with color, private yard has mature shade trees, patio areas enclosed with wood fences. Not only are these homes exceptionally large for the area, but the open floor plans make the living areas very flexible.

Price History

Date
Event
Price
11/06/25
Listing
$1,998,000
07/29/22
Sold
$1,600,000
05/23/17
Sold
$1,219,000
06/21/04
Sold
$950,000
Condition Rating
Fair

Built in 1928, this property has received recent cosmetic updates such as new golden teak hand-scraped wood floors, new carpet, and fresh paint, along with modern central heating and air. However, the kitchen, while functional with a center island and stainless steel refrigerator, features dated honey oak cabinets, older countertops, and standard tile flooring. The visible powder room also appears basic and dated with a pedestal sink. While move-in ready and well-maintained, the key areas of the kitchen and bathrooms show signs of being outdated and would require significant renovation to meet current aesthetic and functional standards, aligning with the 'fair' condition criteria.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Exceptional Income Potential / Versatile Living: A rare '2 on a lot' duplex in Old Towne Orange, offering significant income potential from the guest house or ideal for multi-generational living arrangements.
Prime Historic Location: Situated in the highly desirable Old Towne Orange, just a few blocks from the vibrant plaza, providing excellent walkability and access to local amenities.
Generous Living Space & Flexible Floor Plans: Boasting over 4000 sq. ft. of combined living area, with exceptionally large rooms and open floor plans that offer great flexibility for various lifestyles.
Desirable Amenities & Features: Includes central heating and air in both units, a well-appointed kitchen with a center island and walk-in pantry, multiple primary suites, and four oversized single-car garages.
Charming Aesthetics & Landscaping: Features golden teak hand-scraped wood floors, new blinds and carpet, and beautifully landscaped grounds with mature shade trees and private patio areas, enhancing curb appeal and livability.

Cons

Age-Related Maintenance Concerns: Built in 1928, the property, despite cosmetic updates, may present ongoing maintenance challenges typical of historic homes, potentially requiring significant investment in systems or infrastructure not explicitly mentioned as updated.
Specific Interior Design Elements: Unique features such as the wrap-around bar in the main living room and the enclosed sun room in the primary bedroom are highly specific and may not appeal to all prospective buyers, potentially limiting the buyer pool.
Limited Major System Updates Mentioned: While cosmetic improvements are noted, the description does not detail major system upgrades (e.g., plumbing, electrical, roof) which could be a concern for a property of this age and price point.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse housing market trends by state