243 Selby Lane, Atherton, California 94027, Atherton, 94027 - 6 bed, 4 bath

243 Selby Lane, Atherton, California 94027 home-pic-0
ACTIVE$8,999,000
243 Selby Lane, Atherton, California 94027
6Beds
4Baths
3,455Sqft
43,559Lot
Year Built
1973
Close
-
List price
$9M
Original List price
$9M
Price/Sqft
$2,605
HOA
-
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
ML82026978
Home ConditionExcellent
Features
Good View:
Pool
Patio
View-

About this home

Possibly Over-Priced:The estimated price is 3% below the list price. We found 4 Cons,6 Pros. Rank: price - $9.00M(55th), sqft - 3455(50th), beds - 6(65th), baths - 4(50th).

Discover an unparalleled opportunity for refined living in one of West Atherton's most sought-after cul-de-sacs. Situated on a flat 1-acre lot, this private estate is a sun-drenched sanctuary, perfectly oriented with abundant sunlight and surrounded by a curtain of mature trees. Inside, the newly rejuvenated and updated home in Monterey Colonial style presents a timeless elegance, with formal living and dining rooms for sophisticated gatherings as well as a sun-filled, eat-in kitchen that is the heart of the home. The flow from the inviting family room topped by a cathedral ceiling to the serene backyard creates an ideal space for cherished moments and relaxed entertaining. The upstairs features five spacious bedrooms, while a well-appointed, main-floor office that can also be used as a guest bedroom, with a full-size shower next door. The idyllic grounds, complete with a swimming pool, a verdant lawn, covered patios, and spaces ready for vegetable beds and fruit trees, promise a lifestyle of peace and possibility. This exceptional offering is a masterpiece of potential, all within one of the country's most exclusive settings.

Price History

Date
Event
Price
11/07/25
Listing
$8,999,000
12/05/24
Sold
$7,114,500
06/03/99
Sold
$2,399,000
Condition Rating
Excellent

The property, built in 1973, has been 'newly rejuvenated and updated' as stated in the description, which is strongly supported by the images. The kitchen features modern two-tone cabinetry, high-end stainless steel Bosch appliances, quartz countertops, and contemporary lighting, all appearing brand new. The bathrooms also showcase modern vanities, sleek tiling, updated fixtures, and frameless glass showers, indicating a very recent and extensive renovation. Throughout the home, there is new flooring (hardwood and large format tile), fresh paint, and modern light fixtures. While the underlying structure is older, the comprehensive and high-quality updates mean all components are virtually new and meet current standards, with no deferred maintenance visible, aligning perfectly with the 'excellent' criteria for a property extensively renovated within 5 years.
Pros & Cons

Pros

High Available Lot Utilization: The property has a large lot size, which is more than 4 times of its living area. lot size in square feet = 43559, living area = 3455.
Exclusive Location: Situated in one of West Atherton's most sought-after cul-de-sacs, offering unparalleled exclusivity, privacy, and prestige within a top-tier market.
Generous & Usable Lot: A flat 1-acre lot provides ample space, privacy, abundant sunlight, and is surrounded by mature trees, creating a serene and expansive setting.
Extensive Outdoor Amenities: The idyllic grounds feature a swimming pool, verdant lawn, covered patios, and dedicated spaces for gardening, enhancing the luxury lifestyle.
Updated & Flexible Interior: The home has been newly rejuvenated and updated, featuring a classic Monterey Colonial style, formal living/dining, a sun-filled eat-in kitchen, a family room with a cathedral ceiling, and a flexible main-floor office/guest bedroom.
Ample Accommodation: With five spacious bedrooms upstairs and a versatile main-floor office/guest bedroom with a full bath, the property offers generous living and sleeping arrangements.

Cons

MLS Listing Discrepancy: Living area discrepancy between mls listing and other public or private record. mls listing living area = 3455, other record living area = 3310. Bedroom count discrepancy between mls listing and other public or private record. mls listing bedroom count = 6, other record bedroom count = 5.
Age of Construction: Built in 1973, despite recent rejuvenation, the underlying structure and potentially some core systems may be older, which could necessitate future updates or maintenance beyond cosmetic improvements.
Modest Interior Square Footage: At 3,455 sqft on a 1-acre lot in Atherton, the interior size might be considered modest by some luxury buyers, potentially leading to considerations for expansion or redevelopment to maximize the prime land value.
High Price Point: The nearly $9 million list price, while reflective of the Atherton market, significantly narrows the pool of potential buyers, requiring a very specific and affluent clientele.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse housing market trends by state