5215 Lakeville Highway, Petaluma, CA 94954, Petaluma, 94954 - 6 bed, 6 bath

5215 Lakeville Highway, Petaluma, CA 94954 home-pic-0

5215 Lakeville Highway

Petaluma, CA 94954

ACTIVE
CONDITION: EXCELLENT
6Beds
6Baths
4,483Sq Ft
762,300Lot Size

Property Price

LIST PRICE$3,950,000

SUMMARY

Analysis of 5215 Lakeville Highway, Petaluma, CA 94954 is currently available with a list price of $3,950,000. The property maintains a Excellent Condition Rating (95/100), indicating excellent structural integrity and modern finishes throughout. This turnkey property requires minimal updates and is ready for immediate occupancy. Located in a high-demand neighborhood within the Petaluma Unified School District, this asset is categorized as a low-risk, high-reward acquisition suitable for both Buy-and-Hold Investors and Owner-Occupants willing to undertake light renovation work.

Condition Analysis

OVERALL CONDITION SCORE

Excellent
TeardownExcellent

Property is new construction or fully renovated.

Although originally built in 1899, the property underwent an extensive refurbishment in 2020, placing it within the 5-year window for high-quality renovations. The estate features modern sustainable upgrades including solar power and a private reservoir, and the main residence and surrounding structures appear meticulously maintained and move-in ready with no deferred maintenance.

PROSSTRENGTHS & OPPORTUNITIES

  • High Available Lot Utilization

    The property has a large lot size, which is more than 4 times of its living area. lot size in square feet = 762300, living area = 4483.

  • Permitted Retreat Center

    Uniquely permitted by Sonoma County as a retreat center, the property includes six cottages and a signature barn, offering immediate commercial potential for a boutique B&B or event venue.

  • Sustainable Infrastructure

    The 17.5-acre estate is equipped with solar power and a private reservoir, providing a self-sustaining infrastructure that supports both environmental goals and agricultural operations.

CONSRISKS & DEFICIENCIES

  • MLS Listing Discrepancy

    Bedroom count discrepancy between mls listing and other public or private record. mls listing bedroom count = 6, other record bedroom count = 7.

  • High Maintenance Requirements

    The scale of the 17.5-acre property, combined with multiple secondary structures and a large main residence, necessitates significant ongoing labor and financial investment for upkeep.

  • Legacy Infrastructure Risks

    Despite recent refurbishments, the 125-year-old primary structure may present hidden challenges typical of 19th-century builds, such as aging core systems or foundation complexities.

About 5215 Lakeville Highway

Tucked amid the rolling hills of the Petaluma Gap, Silver Penny Farm is a rare and remarkable retreat where history, nature, and opportunity converge. This 17.5+/- acre property unfolds with pastoral beauty, sweeping pastures, lush gardens, and far-reaching views, creating a setting both serene and inspired. At its heart stands a stately 4,483+/- square-foot farmhouse, offering six bedrooms and five and a half baths, gracefully preserving its historic character while inviting modern vision. Dating back to 1899, the Goldie family modernized the farmhouse in the 1970s and present owners refurbished it in 2020. Surrounding the main residence are six charming cottages, a versatile workshop, and the signature Gathering Barn, a generous space designed for connection and creativity. Permitted by Sonoma County as a retreat center, Silver Penny Farm is more than a home, it's a canvas. Solar power and a private reservoir support a sustainable infrastructure, while its coveted location midway between downtown Petaluma and Sonoma Plaza place it at the gateway of Wine Country. Whether imagined as a boutique B&B, an intimate event venue, a working farm, or a family sanctuary, Silver Penny Farm offers a singular chance to create something extraordinary.

Property Details

Public Facts

Property Type
Single Family Residence
Year Built
1899
Lot Size
762,300 Sq. Ft.

Interior

Total Bedrooms
6
Total Bathrooms
6 (6 Full, 0 Half)

Exterior & Parking

No exterior & parking available.

Utilities & Misc

HOA Fee
$0 / Month

Neighborhood Insights

Sensitive Facilities

No sensitive facilities data found.

Neighborhood Comparison

FeatureSubjectAverage HomeNeighborhood Ranking (50 Listings)
Beds6.04.0
98%
Baths6.02.0
99%
Square foot4,4831,785
98%
Lot Size762,3006,199
98%
Price$3.95M$844.0K
99%
Price per sq ft$881$476
98%
Built year18991975
3%
HOA$0$0
50%
Days on market173170
53%

Pricing History

Listed for Sale

Sep 15, 2025

$3,950,000

Initial Listing

Sold

Aug 15, 2019

$2,900,000

Public Record

Browse Properties by State Browse housing market trends by state