5454 Crestline Drive, Foresthill, CA 95631, Foresthill, 95631 - 3 bed, 2 bath

5454 Crestline Drive, Foresthill, CA 95631 home-pic-0

5454 Crestline Drive

Foresthill, CA 95631

ACTIVE
CONDITION: FAIR
3Beds
2Baths
1,424Sq Ft
40,350Lot Size

Property Price

LIST PRICE$539,000
EST. MARKET VALUE
$433,899
24% AboveMARKET VALUE

SUMMARY

Estimated Market Value

$433,899
Based on Realkey algorithm analyzing recent comparable sales in Foresthill.

Comparable Sales Map

Comparables within 1 miles sold in recently

Address Sold Price BedsBathsSq Ft$/SqftDistance
5454 Crestline Drive
Subject
$539,000*
List Price
321,424$305-
A
5555 Mockingbird Court
Sold
$415,000321,400$2960.4 mi
B
20670 Cedar View Drive
Sold
$424,000331,600$2650.7 mi
C
5191 HAPPY PINES Drive
Sold
$460,000321,400$3290.6 mi
D
5027 Cold Springs Drive
Sold
$509,000231,712$2970.7 mi
E
5431 Nash Court
Sold
$495,000221,576$3140.7 mi
F
21220 Oakwood Lane
Pending
$175,000321,362$3121.0 mi

* Subject property listed price vs sold prices of comps.

Condition Analysis

OVERALL CONDITION SCORE

Fair
TeardownExcellent

Property is moderate renovation needed.

Built in 1977, this property is well-maintained and functional but shows signs of its age, with the listing analysis specifically noting 'dated construction.' While it includes high-value functional upgrades like a Generac generator and a whole house fan, the interior finishes, kitchen, and bathrooms likely require cosmetic modernization to meet contemporary standards. It fits the 'fair' criteria as an aged home maintained through regular upkeep but lacking a recent comprehensive renovation.

PROSSTRENGTHS & OPPORTUNITIES

  • High Available Lot Utilization

    The property has a large lot size, which is more than 4 times of its living area. lot size in square feet = 40350, living area = 1424.

  • Great Schools

    High School: Colfax High School (9/10).

  • ADU and Multi-Generational Potential

    The property features an attached shop with existing electrical and plumbing plus a sun porch, providing approximately 500 square feet of flexible space ideal for a guest suite, rental unit, or home office.

CONSRISKS & DEFICIENCIES

  • Dated Construction

    Built in 1977, the home may require cosmetic updates or modernization of its original systems to meet the aesthetic and efficiency standards of contemporary buyers.

  • Septic System Maintenance

    The reliance on a private septic system rather than a municipal sewer line requires ongoing owner maintenance and may impose limitations on certain types of future lot development.

About 5454 Crestline Drive

Located in the peaceful setting of Todd Valley Estates, this inviting 1,424 sq ft, three-bedroom, two-bath home features an attached shop with electrical and plumbing already in place offering excellent ADU potential for guest quarters, a mother-in-law unit, or future rental income along with a bright sun porch, together providing approximately 500 additional square feet of flexible space not included in the listed square footage. The property sits on nearly one level acre of usable land where privacy and quiet beauty come together. The functional floor plan is designed for comfortable everyday living, while the attached flex space creates exceptional versatility for multigenerational living, a private office, or income-producing opportunities. The sun porch fills the home with natural light and offers a peaceful retreat to relax and enjoy the surrounding landscape year-round. The home is serviced by city water and septic and includes two owned propane tanks, a whole house fan, and a Generac generator, delivering convenience and peace of mind. With ample flat land for gardening, recreation, or future expansion, this property offers a rare blend of usability, flexibility, and mountain charm in a desirable mountain community.

Property Details

Public Facts

Property Type
Single Family Residence
Year Built
1977
Lot Size
40,350 Sq. Ft.

Interior

Total Bedrooms
3
Total Bathrooms
2 (2 Full, 0 Half)

Exterior & Parking

No exterior & parking available.

Utilities & Misc

HOA Fee
$0 / Month

Neighborhood Insights

Foresthill Unified Schools

Foresthill Divide

Grades K-8 • 2.9 mi

5/10

Foresthill Divide Middle School

Grades 5-8 • 3.0 mi

/10

Foresthill High School

Grades 9-12 • 3.4 mi

6/10

Sensitive Facilities

No sensitive facilities data found.

Neighborhood Comparison

FeatureSubjectAverage HomeNeighborhood Ranking (50 Listings)
Beds3.03.0
50%
Baths2.02.0
50%
Square foot1,4241,875
18%
Lot Size40,35047,916
22%
Price$539.0K$495.0K
63%
Price per sq ft$379$269
90%
Built year19771986
27%
HOA$0$0
50%
Days on market37257
2%

Pricing History

Listed for Sale

Jan 29, 2026

$539,000

Initial Listing

Browse Properties by State Browse housing market trends by state