RealKey
‪(213) 433-7766‬

5490 Rutgers Road, La Jolla, California 92037, La Jolla, 92037 - 4 bed, 6 bath

5490 Rutgers Road, La Jolla, California 92037 home-pic-0
ACTIVE$7,595,000
5490 Rutgers Road, La Jolla, California 92037
4Beds
6Baths
4,943Sqft
15,228Lot

Price Vs. Estimate

The estimated value ($5,829,286.12) is $1,765,713.88 (23%) lower than the list price ($7,595,000). This property may be overpriced.

Key pros and cons

Top Pros:
Great Schools: Elementary School: Bird Rock Elementary School (10/10).
Top Cons:
Significant Price Discrepancy: The current listing price of $7.595M is substantially higher than the estimated property value of $5.829M and recent comparable sales in the area, suggesting potential overpricing relative to market expectations.

Compared to the nearby listings

Price:$7.59M vs avg $3.59M (+$4,005,000)90%
Size:4,943 sqft vs avg 2,738 sqft90%
Price/sqft:$1.5K vs avg $1.4K68%

More Insights

Built in 1990 (35 years old).
Condition: Built in 1990, this property boasts high-quality construction and features like a 'gourmet kitchen' and 'luxurious primary suite' that were top-tier for its era. However, the MLS listing explicitly notes a 'Lack of Explicit Recent Renovations' and 'Age of Construction' as weaknesses. While well-maintained, the kitchen and bathroom styles, along with other finishes, are likely reflective of the 1990s and would require updates to meet current luxury standards and buyer expectations for a property at this price point. Major components are functional but show signs of being outdated, aligning with a 'Fair' condition score.
Year Built
1990
Close
-
List price
$7.59M
Original List price
$7.59M
Price/Sqft
$1,537
HOA
-
Days on market
-
Sold On
-
MLS number
NDP2500818
Home ConditionFair
Features
Excellent View: Ocean
Deck
Pool
Patio
ViewOcean

About this home

Discover the exquisite allure of 5490 Rutgers Rd in La Jolla, where contemporary architecture meets breathtaking ocean views at a unique site that faces to both the south and west. This exceptional 4BR/5.5BA residence with bonus rooms including a gym and office boasts an ideal floorplan, with the main living areas, gourmet kitchen, and luxurious primary suite conveniently located on the entry level. Step into a dramatic two-story atrium, flooded with natural light and adorned with floor-to-ceiling windows that instantly draw your gaze to the stunning ocean panorama. The expansive primary suite, open living and dining rooms, and beautifully appointed kitchen all seamlessly embrace these incredible vistas. Even the inviting downstairs family room and pool area offer captivating views of the horizon, twinkling evening lights, and downtown, all while ensuring complete privacy. The master closet is massive and the adjacent bath has its own private ocean view balcony. This luxury home is designed for those who appreciate the finer things in life, featuring wine storage, dedicated office, gym, and spacious 2-plus car garage. Additionally, a separate guest or nanny suite complete with access to a full pool bath enhances the home's versatility. Indulge in outdoor leisure with a sports court, putting green, built-in fire pit in the welcoming entry courtyard, and an array of architecturally striking design elements that provide the perfect backdrop for showcasing a large art collection. The tranquil location, exceptional quality, thoughtful layout, and remarkable features of this home create a truly magical lifestyle that is rarely found.

Nearby schools

10/10
Bird Rock Elementary School
Public,•K-5•0.5mi
7/10
Pacific Beach Elementary School
Public,•K-5•0.5mi
6/10
Pacific Beach Middle School
Public,•6-8•1.2mi
8/10
Muirlands Middle School
Public,•6-8•1.4mi
8/10
La Jolla High School
Public,•9-12•1.6mi
6/10
Mission Bay High School
Public,•9-12•2.1mi
Condition Rating
Fair
Built in 1990, this property boasts high-quality construction and features like a 'gourmet kitchen' and 'luxurious primary suite' that were top-tier for its era. However, the MLS listing explicitly notes a 'Lack of Explicit Recent Renovations' and 'Age of Construction' as weaknesses. While well-maintained, the kitchen and bathroom styles, along with other finishes, are likely reflective of the 1990s and would require updates to meet current luxury standards and buyer expectations for a property at this price point. Major components are functional but show signs of being outdated, aligning with a 'Fair' condition score.
Pros & Cons

Pros

Great Schools: Elementary School: Bird Rock Elementary School (10/10).
Panoramic Ocean & City Views: The property boasts breathtaking ocean views to the south and west, including the horizon, evening lights, and downtown, visible from main living areas, the primary suite, and even the downstairs family room and pool area, all while ensuring complete privacy.
Extensive Luxury Amenities: This home is equipped with a wealth of high-end features including wine storage, a dedicated office, a gym, a spacious 2-plus car garage, a sports court, a putting green, and a built-in fire pit in the entry courtyard.
Exceptional Architectural Design & Layout: Featuring contemporary architecture with a dramatic two-story atrium, floor-to-ceiling windows, and an ideal floorplan that places main living areas, a gourmet kitchen, and the luxurious primary suite on the entry level, designed to maximize natural light and views.
Prime La Jolla Location: Situated in a tranquil and highly sought-after La Jolla location, offering a prestigious address and a desirable lifestyle.
Luxurious Primary Suite: The expansive primary suite is conveniently located on the entry level, featuring a massive master closet and an adjacent bath with its own private ocean view balcony, providing a truly opulent retreat.

Cons

Significant Price Discrepancy: The current listing price of $7.595M is substantially higher than the estimated property value of $5.829M and recent comparable sales in the area, suggesting potential overpricing relative to market expectations.
Age of Construction: Built in 1990, while described as having 'exceptional quality' and 'contemporary architecture,' the property's age may lead potential buyers to question the condition of underlying systems (e.g., HVAC, plumbing, electrical) or require updates to certain finishes to meet current luxury standards.
Lack of Explicit Recent Renovations: The description highlights the home's original contemporary design and features but does not explicitly detail comprehensive, high-end renovations or updates since its 1990 construction, which could be a concern for buyers at this price point expecting the latest in luxury finishes and technology.

Best solution for experienced home buyers!

Data-driven home buying experience with our licensed real estate agents and cutting-edge AI

Browse Properties by State Browse housing market trends by state