5891 Church Street, Foresthill, CA 95631, Foresthill, 95631 - 3 bed, 3 bath
Loading property details...
Foresthill, CA 95631
This Historic Sierra Foothill Residence is listed at $550,000, representing a stable valuation closely aligned with its $528,264 Fair Market Value. Constructed with lumber from the historic Hughes Mill, the property maintains an impressive Condition Rating of 4, offering an exceptionally well-maintained, vintage interior across 2,404 sqft. The expansive half-acre lot features a pear orchard, covered patio, and finished basement, providing a unique blend of architectural history and functional utility. This well-preserved estate is an ideal sanctuary for lifestyle-oriented buyers or history enthusiasts seeking a peaceful mountain retreat.
Comparables within 1 miles sold in recently
| Address | Sold Price | Beds | Baths | Sq Ft | $/Sqft | Distance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
★ 5891 Church Street Subject | $550,000* List Price | 3 | 3 | 2,404 | $220 | - |
A 25681 FORESTHILL Road Active | $445,000 List Price | 3 | 3 | 1,600 | $278 | 1.0 mi |
* Subject property listed price vs sold prices of comps.
Property is moderate renovation needed.
The property is exceptionally well-maintained and clean, but it fits the 'fair' criteria due to its age and the timing of its last major updates. Built in 1949, the home features a kitchen and interior finishes (such as oak cabinetry, vinyl flooring, and black appliances) that appear to date back 20-30 years. While functional and move-in ready, the style is outdated by modern standards. The presence of split units indicates some system updates, but the overall aesthetic and component age align with a property that has been maintained through regular upkeep rather than a recent comprehensive renovation.
The property has a large lot size, which is more than 4 times of its living area. lot size in square feet = 19275, living area = 2404.
Built in 1949 with lumber from the historic Hughes Mill, the home features unique wood walls and ceilings that offer a rare, rustic character and timeless Sierra foothill charm.
The property sits on nearly half an acre and includes a charming pear orchard and covered patio, providing a serene natural setting and ample space for outdoor living.
Lot size discrepancy between mls listing and other public or private record. mls listing lot size in square feet =19275, other record lot size in square feet = 19344.
Given its 1949 construction, the property may require updates to older systems or specialized maintenance to preserve its historic wood-heavy interior and structural integrity.
While offering a peaceful escape, the 20-minute commute to the freeway in Auburn may be less convenient for residents who require quick daily access to major urban centers.
HISTORIC CHARM, ORCHARD SETTING, AND FOOTHILL LIVING * Built in 1949 using lumber milled by the historic Hughes Mill, this one-of-a-kind home blends timeless craftsmanship, rustic character, and peaceful Sierra foothill living in the heart of historic downtown Foresthill. Set on nearly half an acre and surrounded by a charming pear orchard, the property offers space and natural beauty just 20 minutes from the freeway in Auburn making it an ideal escape while still staying connected to surrounding communities. Originally built by the owner of Hughes Mill, much of the lumber throughout the home was milled specifically for this residence. The result is a warm and distinctive interior featuring beautiful wood walls and ceilings that showcase the craftsmanship of another era. With 2,404 square feet of living space, the home offers a spacious and inviting floor plan with three bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths. Large, comfortable living areas are designed for both everyday living and easy entertaining. At the center of the home, the kitchen provides a welcoming gathering place with a large island perfect for family meals or entertaining guests. Thoughtful details include a charming backsplash, built-in refrigerator, stovetop, and a convenient kitchen bar that allows the cook to stay connected with the conversation. The living room offers a warm and inviting space to relax and unwind, with the opportunity to create a cozy fireplace focal point for cool Sierra foothill evenings. Upstairs bedrooms provide generous space and peaceful retreats, complete with split units for comfort. A finished basement adds flexibility for hobbies, storage, or additional living space. Step outside to enjoy the property's tranquil outdoor setting. A covered patio invites outdoor entertaining, while the pear orchard and open space create a serene connection to nature. The home's distinctive gambrel roofline adds architectural charm. Additional features include a two-car garage and RV parking, providing both convenience and versatility. Enjoy the charm and walkability of historic downtown Foresthill while remaining just 20 minutes from the freeway in Auburn. For those seeking expanded possibilities, the neighboring property is also available, offering a rare opportunity to create a private family compound, multi-generational retreat, or expanded estate. This special property offers a unique blend of history and craftmanship-a home with a story ready for its next chapter.
No exterior & parking available.
No sensitive facilities data found.
| Feature | Subject | Average Home | Neighborhood Ranking (50 Listings) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Beds | 3.0 | 3.0 | 50% |
| Baths | 3.0 | 2.0 | 53% |
| Square foot | 2,404 | 1,725 | 78% |
| Lot Size | 19,275 | 45,738 | 14% |
| Price | $550.0K | $455.0K | 78% |
| Price per sq ft | $229 | $264 | 31% |
| Built year | 1949 | 1988 | 3% |
| HOA | $0 | $0 | 50% |
| Days on market | 45 | 244 | 3% |
Mar 8, 2026
$550,000
Initial Listing